“WITH iPods and iPads and Xboxes and PlayStationsâ€”none of which I know how to workâ€”information becomes a distraction, a diversion, a form of entertainment, rather than a tool of empowerment.”
In a speech to students at Hampton University on May 9th, Mr Obama did not just name-check some big brands; he also joined a long tradition of grumbling about new technologies and new forms of media.
Socrates’s bugbear was the spread of the biggest-ever innovation in communicationsâ€”writing. He feared that relying on written texts, rather than the oral tradition, would â€œcreate forgetfulness in the learners’ soulsâ€¦they will trust to the external written characters and not remember of themselves.â€
Enos Hitchcock voiced a widespread concern about the latest publishing fad in 1790. â€œThe free access which many young people have to romances, novels and plays has poisoned the mind and corrupted the morals of many a promising youth.â€ (There was a related worry that sofas, introduced at the same time, encouraged young people to drift off into fantasy worlds.)
Cinema was denounced as â€œan evil pure and simpleâ€ in 1910; comic books were said to lead children into delinquency in 1954; rock’n’roll was accused of turning the young into â€œdevil worshippersâ€ in 1956; Hillary Clinton attacked video games for â€œstealing the innocence of our childrenâ€ in 2005.
Mr Obama complained that technology was putting â€œnew pressures on our country and on our democracyâ€. But iPods, iPads and suchlike are not to blame for the crazy theoriesâ€”about, for instance, politicians’ birth certificatesâ€”that circulate in the blogosphere.
People have always traded gossip: the internet just makes it easier and quicker. The culprit is human nature, not technology. And new communications technologies tend to strengthen democracy, not weaken it, as revolutionaries have known ever since Thomas Paine and others used the printing press to argue for American independence.
At least Mr Obama got one thing right: the idea that educating people is the best way to enable them to adapt to technological change, and use it for good. But technology is not an alternative to education and empowerment; it can, in fact, help deliver them. America’s first web-savvy president should understand that.